Chances are you’re looking at BMW models if you want a luxury crossover that drives well. If so, you should pay attention to the X1 and X3 models.
Since they are different in important ways, here are some things to think about when making your choice!
Differences Between the BMW X1 and X3
The X1 and X3 are different in a lot of ways, like price, gas mileage, cargo space, and powertrain options. Here are the most important differences between the two, broken down by which features are most important to you.
1. Cargo Space
Since the X3 is bigger than the X5, you might think it has more space for cargo. If so, your guess is right, and by a very large amount!
When the seats are back, the BMW X3 has 28.7 cubic feet of space, which is 1.6 cubic feet more than the X1. Even though this may not seem like a big difference to you, it is.
When the seats are folded, there is a bigger difference in the amount of space for cargo. This means that the X3’s cargo space grows to a large 62.7 cubic feet, which is more than four cubic feet more than the X1.
The bigger BMW X3 has more space for cargo than its rival, but you might be surprised to learn that the smaller BMW X1 has more room for your head and legs.
Even though the X3 is getting a makeover, the new X1 has taken what worked in the X3 and other models and put it all together in a winning way.
Even though the differences aren’t too big, even an inch here or there can make a big difference in how comfortable you and your passengers are. The X1 has 37 inches of legroom and the X3 has 36.4 inches. The X1 has 39.4 inches of headroom, while the X3 has 39.1 inches.
If the price of a BMW crossover or SUV is important to you, you should look more closely at the X1, which clearly beats the X3 in this category.
Since the X1 is smaller, you can buy it for just under $36,200 and still get a lot of great features, like a rearview camera, leather seats and steering wheel, and an infotainment system that is almost nine inches.
You can expect to pay close to $44,000 for an X3. But you will get a car that comes with standard all-wheel drive and a rear-wheel drive platform. If you’ve owned a BMW before, this will remind you of the traditional feel you get when driving this luxury brand.
4. Fuel Economy
The BMW X1 gets better gas mileage than the X3 because it has a smaller engine with only four cylinders.
The X1 gets a good 33 miles per gallon on the highway, while the X3 gets a good 29 miles per gallon.
The powertrain is the one area where the X3 is clearly better than the X1. You can get a 2.0-liter supercharged engine for the X1 that gives you 228 horsepower and 258 pound-feet of torque.
With the X3’s six-cylinder engine, which is supercharged, you can get 328 horsepower.
Even when going faster, the X3 usually comes out on top, but not by as much as you might think. For the X1 with four cylinders, it takes six seconds to go from 0 to 60 mph.
If you give the six-cylinder X3 gas, you can expect to go from 0 to 60 miles per hour in as little as 4.4 seconds.
Is the X3 Better than the X1?
How you answer this question will depend a lot on what features you value most when you’re driving.
If you’ll be using your car to go shopping, drive your kids to and from school, soccer games, and other places, and take family trips where you’ll need to carry camping gear and other things, the larger X3 may be your best choice.
But if your main goal is to use your car to get to and from work and you want to save as much gas as possible, the smaller X1 with its four-cylinder engine will probably be a good choice.
Both the X1 and the X3 get high marks for how reliable they are.
Since BMW is known for making cars that don’t break down much, it’s likely that you won’t have to spend a lot of money on unexpected repairs no matter which of the two you choose.
When car experts were asked to choose between the two, most agreed that the X3 was better, but only by a small amount. Most of the time, the extra cargo space, power, and all-wheel drive are what make the difference.
Is the BMW X1 a Good Buy?
Overall, auto experts and consumers agree that the BMW X1 is a good buy for the money. If you want a luxury crossover but don’t have a lot of money to spend on a car, the X1 is a good choice. It’s fast, comfortable, and reliable, and the price is right.
Even though the X1 is different from the X3 in that it has front-wheel drive instead of all-wheel drive (AWD), it still has a smooth ride and enough features, like an infotainment system and 18-inch wheels, to make it a good buy. All of these things, plus the fact that it gets great gas mileage and has surprising speed, make it a good buy.
No matter which of these BMW models you choose, you can be sure that you will get a car that will do everything you need and more.
Whether you choose the X1 because you want to save money or the X3 because you want more power and luxury, you will soon be able to drive on the highway or around town in a reliable BMW for many years to come!